The University of Mary Washington has developed a reputation on a national scale as one of the top NCAA Division III athletic programs. Since 1981, the Eagles have seen 350 student-athletes gain the ultimate recognition as All-America selections.
| 2023-24 | Josh Kirkland | M. Soccer |
| Carter Berg | M. Soccer | |
| Gabe Francesconi | M. Soccer | |
| Jordan Lyons | Volleyball | |
| Jordan Carpenter | W. Basketball | |
| Kinsey Brooks | W. Swimming | |
| 2022-23 | Krista Rodgers | Volleyball |
| Josh Kirkland | M. Soccer | |
| Greg Rowson | M. Basketball | |
| Jordan Carpenter | W. Basketball | |
| Kinsey Brooks | W. Swimming | |
| Keegan Shipe | M. Lacrosse | |
| Katie Blair | W. Lacrosse | |
| Cailyn Tripp | W. Lacrosse | |
| 2021-22 | Kinsey Brooks | W. Swimming |
| Bill Tamani | M. Rugby | |
| Moses Hutchison | M. Tennis | |
| Andrew Watson | M. Tennis | |
| Abby Moghtader | W. Tennis | |
| Lauren Quinn | W. Tennis | |
| 2020-21 | Moses Hutchison | M. Tennis |
| Abby Moghtader | W. Tennis | |
| Lauren Quinn | W. Tennis | |
| 2019-20 | Peyton Dunow | Volleyball |
| Savannah Powers | Volleyball | |
| Gabriel Soriano | M. Soccer | |
| 2018-19 | Savannah Powers | Volleyball |
| Justin Carey | M. Soccer | |
| Jeff Leckrone | M. Swimming | |
| Julia Albert | W. Lacrosse | |
| Hanna Ashby | W. Lacrosse | |
| Mackenzie Maguire | W. Lacrosse | |
| Erin Andrewlevich | W. Track & Field | |
| Rachel Summers | W. Tennis | |
| Matt Miles | M. Tennis | |
| Moses Hutchison | M. Tennis | |
| Matthew Gordon | M. Rugby | |
| Harry Masters | M. Rugby | |
| 2017-18 | Sebastien Bonte | M. Golf |
| Kirsten Littlefield | W. Lacrosse | |
| Mackenzie Maguire | W. Lacrosse | |
| Derek Hagino | M. Tennis | |
| Patrick Hughes | M. Tennis | |
| Ashley Barrow | W. Tennis | |
| Kait Brogan | W. Tennis | |
| Rachel Summers | W. Tennis | |
| 2016-17 | Emma Olson | Volleyball |
| Christine Loehr | Field Hockey | |
| Brianne Comden | W. Basketball | |
| Dallas Tarkenton | M. Swimming | |
| Anna Corley | W. Swimming | |
| Kirsten Littlefield | W. Lacrosse | |
| Hanna Ashby | W. Lacrosse | |
| Kait Brogan | W. Tennis | |
| Taylor Diffley | W. Tennis | |
| 2015-16 | Jenna Steele | Field Hockey |
| Haley Kane | Field Hockey | |
| Brianne Comden | W. Basketball | |
| Dallas Tarkenton | M. Swimming | |
| Anna Corley | W. Swimming | |
| Katie Fago | W. Swimming | |
| Hannah Hagy | W. Swimming | |
| Stephanie Hallock | W. Swimming | |
| Kirsten Littlefield | W. Lacrosse | |
| Kait Brogan | W. Tennis | |
| Shelby Harris | W. Tennis | |
| 2014-15 | Haley Kane | Field Hockey |
| Alex Anderson | M. Swimming | |
| Jono Haught | Baseball | |
| Tyler Carey | M. Tennis | |
| 2013-14 | Caitlin Baker | Field Hockey |
| Luke Dick | M. Lacrosse | |
| Jenna Petrucelli | W. Lacrosse | |
| Alex Anderson | M. Swimming | |
| Jessica Singer | W. Swimming | |
| Lindsay Raulston | W. Tennis | |
| Shelby Harris | W Tennis | |
| 2012-13 | Caitlin Baker | Field Hockey |
| Lisa Charney | Field Hockey | |
| Katie Mastropaolo | W. Lacrosse | |
| Alex Anderson | M. Swimming | |
| Nickolas Eckhoff | M. Swimming | |
| Peter Slattery | M. Swimming | |
| Misha Yelmgren | M. Swimming | |
| Amber Kerico | W. Swimming | |
| Tyler Carey | M. Tennis | |
| Shelby Harris | W. Tennis | |
| Lindsay Raulston | W. Tennis | |
| 2011-12 | Catherine Kennedy | W. Lacrosse |
| Allie Kimmelman | W. Lacrosse | |
| Alex Anderson | M. Swimming | |
| Amber Kerico | W. Swimming | |
| Evan Charles | M. Tennis | |
| Donato Rizzolo | M. Tennis | |
| Lindsay Raulston | W. Tennis | |
| 2010-11 | Catherine Kennedy | W. Lacrosse |
| Stephen Clendenin | M. Swimming | |
| William Norfolk | M. Swimming | |
| 2009-10 | Frank DeVar | Cross Country |
| Catherine Kennedy | W. Lacrosse | |
| Allie Kimmelman | W. Lacrosse | |
| Karolyn Milton | W. Rowing | |
| Stephen Clendenin | M. Swimming | |
| Sarah Crockett | W. Swimming | |
| Megan DeSmit | W. Swimming | |
| Cameron Figuers | W. Swimming | |
| Adriana Lesiuk | W. Swimming | |
| Nina Michelle Sawyer | W. Swimming | |
| Evan Goff | M. Tennis | |
| Kaz Murata | M. Tennis | |
| Matt Cash | Track & Field | |
| 2008-09 | Catherine Kennedy | W. Lacrosse |
| Allie Kimmelman | W. Lacrosse | |
| Stephen Clendenin | M. Swimming | |
| Sarah Crockett | W. Swimming | |
| John James | M. Tennis | |
| Randy Loden | M. Tennis | |
| Kate Malpeli | W. Tennis | |
| Becky Morse-Karzen | W. Tennis | |
| Justin German | Track & Field | |
| 2007-08 | Liz Hickey | W. Basketball |
| Caitlin Erickson | W. Lacrosse | |
| Natassya Bedos | W. Rowing | |
| Lorena de la Garza | W. Swimming | |
| John James | M. Tennis | |
| Randy Loden | M. Tennis | |
| Kaz Murata | M. Tennis | |
| Natalia Fugate | W. Tennis | |
| Stephanie Kurti | W. Tennis | |
| Becky Morse-Karzen | W. Tennis | |
| Matt Cash | Track & Field | |
| Cristy Falcone | Track & Field | |
| Mae Winchester | Track & Field | |
| 2006-07 | Debbie Bruen | W. Basketball |
| Liz Hickey | W. Basketball | |
| Kaitlyn Barker | W. Lacrosse | |
| Meaghan O’Leary | W. Lacrosse | |
| Kelley Tice | W. Rowing | |
| Dale Parker | M. Swimming | |
| Amy Carlson | W. Swimming | |
| Mallory Cruise | W. Swimming | |
| Lorena de la Garza | W. Swimming | |
| Patricia Dilger | W. Swimming | |
| Maureen Greenlee | W. Swimming | |
| Kristen LaCoe | W. Swimming | |
| Nina Michelle Sawyer | W. Swimming | |
| John James | M. Tennis | |
| Stephanie Kurti | W. Tennis | |
| Becky Morse-Karzen | W. Tennis | |
| 2005-06 | Debbie Bruen | W. Basketball |
| Liz Hickey | W. Basketball | |
| Brynn Maguire | Field Hockey | |
| Kaitlyn Barker | W. Lacrosse | |
| Caitlin O’Leary | W. Lacrosse | |
| Kelley Tice | W. Rowing | |
| Dale Parker | M. Swimming | |
| Amy Carlson | W. Swimming | |
| Mallory Cruise | W. Swimming | |
| Lorena de la Garza | W. Swimming | |
| Patricia Dilger | W. Swimming | |
| Maureen Greenlee | W. Swimming | |
| Paul Bristow | M. Tennis | |
| Randy Loden | M. Tennis | |
| 2004-05 | Brynn Maguire | Field Hockey |
| Kelley Tice | W. Rowing | |
| Dale Parker | M. Swimming | |
| Lorena de la Garza | W. Swimming | |
| Paul Bristow | M. Tennis | |
| Nate Hathaway | M. Tennis | |
| James Eberhardt | Track & Field | |
| 2003-04 | Kevin Foeman | Baseball |
| Chrissy Soper | Field Hockey | |
| Melissa Block | W. Lacrosse | |
| Kelley Tice | W. Rowing | |
| Paul Bristow | M. Tennis | |
| Tim Ryan | M. Tennis | |
| Dan Uyar | M. Tennis | |
| 2002-03 | Meghan McMahon | Field Hockey |
| Melissa Block | W. Lacrosse | |
| Kate Clute | W. Lacrosse | |
| Kami McNinch | W. Lacrosse | |
| Christina Galligan | W. Rowing | |
| Kathy Wainwright | W. Soccer | |
| Justin Snyder | M. Swimming | |
| Kevin Loden | M. Tennis | |
| Conor Smith | M. Tennis | |
| Dan Uyar | M. Tennis | |
| Bobby Bergin | Track & Field | |
| Peter Diamond | Track & Field | |
| 2001-02 | Christine Ballance | Field Hockey |
| Jessica Morris | Field Hockey | |
| Beth Curran | W. Lacrosse | |
| Briana Gervat | W. Lacrosse | |
| Justin Snyder | M. Swimming | |
| Conor Smith | M. Tennis | |
| Bobby Bergin | Track & Field | |
| Erik Kochert | Track & Field | |
| 2000-01 | Jessica Morris | Field Hockey |
| Bridget Geiman | W. Lacrosse | |
| Kate Weller | W. Lacrosse | |
| Briana Gervat | W. Lacrosse | |
| Justin Snyder | M. Swimming | |
| Lisa-Marie Carlson | W. Swimming | |
| Tamara Jones | W. Swimming | |
| Amanda Kohne | W. Swimming | |
| Karin Riesenfeld | W. Swimming | |
| Lea Schon | W. Tennis | |
| Ashley Knapp | W. Tennis | |
| Peter Diamond | Track & Field | |
| Erik Kochert | Track & Field | |
| Mike Merker | Track & Field | |
| Andy Ivie | Track & Field | |
| Jon Thompson | Track & Field | |
| 1999-00 | Erin Caulfield | W. Basketball |
| Jenni Foy | W. Lacrosse | |
| Bridget Geiman | W. Lacrosse | |
| Diane Grimm | W. Lacrosse | |
| Kate Weller | W. Lacrosse | |
| Ellen Anderson | W. Soccer | |
| Mariah Butler | W. Swimming | |
| Lisa-Marie Carlson | W. Swimming | |
| Amanda Kohne | W. Swimming | |
| Leslie Morgan | W. Swimming | |
| Kim Myers | W. Swimming | |
| Karin Riesenfeld | W. Swimming | |
| Lea Schon | W. Tennis | |
| Kim Alvis | Track & Field | |
| Yurissa Mitchell | Track & Field | |
| 1998-99 | Erin Broome | Field Hockey |
| Melissa Ballance | W. Lacrosse | |
| Bridget Geiman | W. Lacrosse | |
| Johanna Klein | W. Soccer | |
| Mariah Butler | W. Swimming | |
| Kim Myers | W. Swimming | |
| Lea Schon | W. Tennis | |
| Kim Alvis | Track & Field | |
| Kathleen Edwards | Track & Field | |
| Yurissa Mitchell | Track & Field | |
| 1997-98 | Adam Natysin | Baseball |
| Lindsay Stover | W. Basketball | |
| Melissa Ballance | W. Lacrosse | |
| Craig Gillan | M. Soccer | |
| Felicity Smith | W. Soccer | |
| Chris Rice | M. Swimming | |
| Mariah Butler | W. Swimming | |
| Kim Myers | W. Swimming | |
| Megan Reese | W. Swimming | |
| Yurissa Mitchell | Track & Field | |
| 1996-97 | Jeff Hootselle | Baseball |
| Jon Gates | Cross Country | |
| Charlotte Cockrell | Field Hockey | |
| Charlotte Cockrell | W. Lacrosse | |
| Chris Rice | M. Swimming | |
| Tim Selgas | M. Swimming | |
| Mariah Butler | W. Swimming | |
| Megan Reese | W. Swimming | |
| Chris Wallace | M. Tennis | |
| Jon Gates | Track & Field | |
| 1995-96 | Jin Wong | Baseball |
| Stefanie Teter | W. Basketball | |
| Carin Gsellman | Field Hockey | |
| Eliza Huber | Field Hockey | |
| Amy Halter | W. Lacrosse | |
| Eliza Huber | W. Lacrosse | |
| Tricia Kube | W. Lacrosse | |
| Jeff Kramer | M. Soccer | |
| Eliza Barcus | W. Swimming | |
| Liz Darcy | W. Swimming | |
| Jessica Green | W. Swimming | |
| Gretchen Hurley | W. Swimming | |
| Sarah King | W. Swimming | |
| Emily Williams | W. Swimming | |
| Tim Selgas | M. Swimming | |
| Myra Simpson | Track & Field | |
| 1994-95 | Michelle O’Hanlon | Field Hockey |
| Bridget Rooney | Field Hockey | |
| Eliza Huber | W. Lacrosse | |
| Stefanie Teter | W. Soccer | |
| Sarah King | W. Swimming | |
| Megan Reese | W. Swimming | |
| Myra Simpson | Track & Field | |
| 1993-94 | April Moshos | Field Hockey |
| Candice Malone | Field Hockey | |
| Tommy Walthall | M. Soccer | |
| Leslie Roland | W. Tennis | |
| 1992-93 | April Moshos | Field Hockey |
| Amanda Clair | W. Swimming | |
| Liz Darcy | W. Swimming | |
| Amanda Dresser | W. Swimming | |
| Sarah Hertz | W. Swimming | |
| Shannon Hutcherson | W. Swimming | |
| Sarah King | W. Swimming | |
| Pia Holm | W. Tennis | |
| Leslie Roland | W. Tennis | |
| Tammy Buhite | Track & Field | |
| Lesley Krush | Track & Field | |
| 1991-92 | Jennifer Freed | Field Hockey |
| Lisa Peterson | W. Lacrosse | |
| Erin Patrick | W. Soccer | |
| Amanda Dresser | W. Swimming | |
| Tammy Buhite | Track & Field | |
| 1990-91 | Don Purcell | Baseball |
| Kim Cosgriff | Cross Country | |
| Ronni Pile | W.. Soccer | |
| Dawn Anderson | W. Swimming | |
| Shannon Brown | W. Swimming | |
| Tammy Cakouros | W. Swimming | |
| Amanda Clair | W. Swimming | |
| Susan Debruhl | W. Swimming | |
| Sarah Hertz | W. Swimming | |
| Stephanie Weekes | W. Swimming | |
| Christy Copper | W. Tennis | |
| Tammy Buhite | Track & Field | |
| Kim Cosgriff | Track & Field | |
| Leigh Ann Winston | Track & Field | |
| 1989-90 | Liz Wheeler | W. Lacrosse |
| Shane Shackford | M. Soccer | |
| Diane DeFalco | W. Soccer | |
| Christy Copper | W. Tennis | |
| Kim Cosgriff | Track & Field | |
| 1988-89 | Melissa Grant | W. Lacrosse |
| Shane Shackford | M. Soccer | |
| Diane DeFalco | W. Soccer | |
| Shannon Brown | W. Swimming | |
| Tammy Cakouros | W. Swimming | |
| Diana Sievers | W. Swimming | |
| Kristen Spencer | W. Swimming | |
| Mitzi Kimball | W. Tennis | |
| Christy Copper | W. Tennis | |
| Sean Carpenter | Track & Field | |
| 1987-88 | Suzy Baughman | W. Lacrosse |
| Shane Shackford | M. Soccer | |
| Debbie Eicher | W. Soccer | |
| Mitzi Kimball | W. Tennis | |
| Noelle Labar | W. Tennis | |
| 1986-87 | Buddy Hawley | M. Basketball |
| Peggy McKelvey | Cross Country | |
| Pam Heller | W. Lacrosse | |
| Rene Thomas | W. Lacrosse | |
| Sharon Eliasek | W. Lacrosse | |
| 1985-86 | Pam Heller | W. Lacrosse |
| 1984-85 | Bill Lohr | M. Soccer |
| 1983-84 | Deeanne Wardman | W. Tennis |
| 1981-82 | Deb Reid | Field Hockey |
| Kathy Devine | W. Tennis | |
| Mary Glowacki | W. Tennis | |
| Patsy O’Connell | W. Tennis | |
| Jamie Rund | W. Tennis | |
| Deeanne Wardman | W. Tennis | |
| Terry Hudacheck | Track & Field | |
| Kathy McCaughey | Track & Field | |
| Marlene Moreno | Track & Field | |
| Chris Scott | Track & Field | |
| Terry Rose | Track & Field | |