| 1994 | Women's At‐Large | Candice Malone | 2 | Field Hockey |
| Women's At‐Large | Stacy Sanders | 3 | Track & Field | |
| 1995 | Women's At‐Large | Etta Agan | 1 | Track & Field |
| 1996 | Women's At‐Large | Kristen Erickson | 3 | Tennis |
| 1998 | Women's At‐Large | Angie Saulsbury | 3 | Field Hockey |
| 2000 | Women's At‐Large | Bridget Geiman | 2 | Lacrosse |
| 2001 | Women's At‐Large | Bridget Geiman | 2 | Lacrosse |
| Women's Soccer | Rebecca Vaccaro | 3 | D | |
| 2002 | Men's Track/Cross Country | Erik Kochert | 2 | |
| 2009 | Men's Track/Cross Country | Justin German | 3 | |
| 2015 | Women's Track/Cross Country | Claire Harrington | 1 | |
| 2016 | Women's At‐Large | Haley Kane | 1 | Field Hockey |