| Year | Male | Female |
| 2012-13 | Alex Anderson (M. Swimming) | Lisa Charney (Field Hockey) |
| 2013-14 | Alex Anderson (M. Swimming) | Caitlin Baker (Field Hockey) |
| Bradley Riester (M. Basketball) | ||
| 2014-15 | Alex Anderson (M. Swimming) | Teagan Young (W. XC/Track) |
| 2015-16 | Dallas Tarkenton (M. Swimming) | Jenna Steele (Field Hockey) |
| T.J. Jones (M. Basketball) | ||
| 2016-17 | Dallas Tarkenton (M. Swimming) | Emma Olson (Volleyball) |
| 2017-18 | Colin Travis (M. Soccer) | Kirsten Littlefield (Lacrosse) |
| Eric Shaw (M. Basketball) | ||
| 2018-19 | Justin Carey (M. Soccer) | Erin Andrewlevich (W. Track) |
| Jeff Leckrone (M. Swimming) | Hanna Ashby (W. Lacrosse) | |
| 2019-20 | Gabriel Soriano (M. Soccer) | Savannah Powers (Volleyball) |
| Noah Carpenter (M. Swimming) | Erin Andrewlevich (W. Track) | |
| Moses Hutchison (M. Tennis) | Paige Haskins (W. Lacrosse) | |
| 2020-21 | Sebastien Bonte (M. Golf) | Rylie Cole (W. Lacrosse) |
| Moses Hutchison (M. Tennis) | ||
| 2021-22 | Moses Hutchison (M. Tennis) | Kinsey Brooks (W. Swimming) |
| 2022-23 | Josh Kirkland (M. Soccer) | Kinsey Brooks (W. Swimming) |
| Greg Rowson (M. Basketball) |